UK cheesemongers may discover mould on tasty commerce treaty with Japan


FT premium subscribers can click here to obtain Commerce Secrets and techniques by electronic mail

Greetings from Tokyo. The large commerce prize left on the agenda for the 12 months is the massive, pan-Asian Regional Complete Financial Partnership, which members say is essentially full. Earlier than finishing that deal, nevertheless, Japan had time for an aperitif within the type of a UK-Japan deal, agreed in document time to be prepared earlier than the transition interval between the UK and the EU ends.

Total, the UK-Japan deal marks a robust begin for the UK’s commerce negotiators. Regardless of time strain and inexperience, they reached an settlement that broadly maintains current EU-Japan preparations. In areas corresponding to agricultural quotas, nevertheless, the UK wanted new concessions from Japan simply to keep up the established order and needed to accept a doubtful compromise as a substitute. Right now’s be aware seems at what entry UK farmers must the Japanese market. Our coverage watch examines the waning prospects for a fast UK-US commerce deal, whereas our chart of the day focuses on how producers are adjusting their provide chains away from China.

Don’t overlook to click here in case you’d wish to obtain Commerce Secrets and techniques each Monday to Thursday. And we wish to hear from you. Ship any ideas to or electronic mail me at

Roquefort vs Stilton

As is so usually the case in commerce negotiations, the hardest problem in latest talks between the UK and Japan was agriculture. The UK needed quotas to promote foodstuffs corresponding to cheese, changing these it can lose when it leaves the EU. Tokyo went into the negotiation promising its farmers there could be no new quotas. It was fairly a conundrum, however nothing a wily commerce negotiator couldn’t deal with.

The deal agreed with the UK allowed Japan's foreign minister Toshimitsu Motegi, right, to declare there were ‘no new quotas’
The deal agreed with the UK allowed Japan’s overseas minister Toshimitsu Motegi, proper, to declare there have been ‘no new quotas’ © REUTERS

The answer the 2 sides got here up with is uncommon: for 10 out of the 25 tariff charge quotas within the EU-Japan deal, the UK will be capable to use any quota left over by the EU. For instance, if the EU cheese quota is 20,000 tonnes, and Japan imports solely 18,000 tonnes from Europe, then the UK will be capable to use the remaining 2,000 tonnes. That allowed Japanese overseas minister Toshimitsu Motegi to declare there have been “no new quotas” whereas London said proudly, “We are going to proceed to learn from entry to the low tariffs for key foods and drinks merchandise coated by quotas, corresponding to Stilton cheese.”

In principle, everyone seems to be completely happy — however the settlement begs a query: will there be any unused quotas left over for the UK? Although it’s unattainable to say for sure, and can range 12 months by 12 months, a number of of probably the most enticing quotas are already totally used. The UK’s cheesemongers danger discovering that their tasty new treaty has mould on it.

The EU-Japan deal creates a soft cheese quota that will get greater yearly whereas the tariff charge utilized to it will get decrease. In 12 months one, the EU can export 20,000 tonnes of cheese to Japan with a 27.9 per cent tariff (in contrast with a standard tariff of 29.8 per cent). By 12 months 10, that’s 26,100 tonnes at an 11.2 per cent tariff, and by 12 months 16 it’s 31,000 tonnes tariff-free. With yearly that goes by, due to this fact, there’s more room within the quota however utilizing it turns into extra enticing.

The quotas within the deal comply with the Japanese fiscal 12 months from April to March and the treaty is now in 12 months three of implementation. In 2019, there was certainly area left in most of the quotas. Solely 11,858 tonnes of EU cheese have been imported underneath the deal in contrast with 20,600 tonnes of accessible quota. Not a single tonne of the massive quota for malt was used. The one items that took up all of the accessible quota within the EU-Japan deal have been butter and milk powder. That area is little doubt why the compromise labored for the British and Japanese negotiators.

Up to now in 2020, nevertheless, the 21,200 tonne quota for cheese is already fully allocated and so are the quotas for butter, skimmed milk, cake mixes and tea and occasional preparations. Simply 2,406 tonnes of cheese quota was handed again for reallocation in September, when it was 1.3 occasions oversubscribed. UK producers must wait and see whether or not a few of that also goes unused on the finish of the 12 months.

In 2019, that did occur, however the state of affairs highlights the vagaries of the mechanism. Will UK producers have to attend till the very finish of the 12 months and rush to make use of any remaining quota? Will they be mechanically allotted quota left over from 2020 to make use of in 2021? Will any Japanese importer purchase from Britain with such uncertainty about tariffs from 12 months to 12 months? Total, Japan imports greater than 100,000 tonnes of cheese a 12 months from Europe. Because the tariff charge throughout the quota falls, Japanese shoppers are prone to discover it’s French Roquefort filling their retailers, not British Stilton.

Charted waters

Pushed by President Donald Trump’s push to “decouple” the US financial system from China and the disruptions attributable to the coronavirus pandemic, many producers are being forced to rethink their presence in China, writes Kathrin Hille. At a time when tensions between Washington and Beijing are more and more starting to resemble a brand new chilly conflict, merchandise starting from laptop servers to the Apple iPhone may find yourself having two separate provide chains — one for the Chinese language market and one for a lot of the remainder of the world. Contract producers of servers corresponding to Taiwan-based Quanta Pc have began shifting some manufacturing again dwelling and a few to the US or Mexico.

Chart showing cost of making a hypothetical product, selected countries ($). Mexico is undercutting China for low-cost manufacturing

Coverage watch

UK trade secretary Liz Truss admitted in July there would not be a UK-US deal any time soon
UK commerce secretary Liz Truss admitted in July there wouldn’t be a UK-US deal any time quickly © NEIL HALL/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock

Commerce talks between the UK and US have been already going through mounting obstacles earlier than UK prime minister Boris Johnson’s menace to rewrite his Brexit divorce treaty drew anger from senior politicians in Washington, writes Aime Williams.

Lauded as one of many nice prizes for post-Brexit Britain, main figures in Mr Trump’s administration have been promising in February {that a} US-UK commerce deal was “high of the listing” of priorities. However UK commerce secretary Liz Truss admitted in July there wouldn’t be a deal any time quickly. Now, nearly eight months later and after 4 rounds of talks, officers and commerce consultants acknowledge {that a} lengthy street still lies ahead.

UK hopes of clinching a take care of Mr Trump earlier than the presidential election — now plunged into turmoil by the president’s coronavirus analysis — have rapidly pale. Whereas officers on either side converse positively of the progress made to this point, they acknowledge the difficulties of conducting commerce negotiations largely on-line resulting from restrictions imposed by the pandemic. Moreover, probably the most contentious points round agriculture and meals requirements, market entry for US drug firms, and guidelines of origin are solely within the very early phases of being mentioned.

Don’t miss

  • Coronavirus outbreaks have repeatedly been linked to firms with the worst working situations, shining an unflattering mild on to the provision chains of developed nations. A part of an FTfm particular report on Accountable Investing, this piece seems at how you can make enterprise repair provide chain flaws.
    Read more

  • The US, Europe and the UK should unite to maintain Chinese language tech at bay, writes Anja Manuel within the FT, with nice powers all the time triumphing because of their technological edge.
    Read more

  • Indonesia has handed a invoice that may overhaul a number of dozen tax and labour market legal guidelines as south-east Asia’s largest financial system strives to spice up overseas funding and counter the financial influence of coronavirus. 
    Read more

Tokyo discuss

The very best commerce tales from Nikkei Asia

  • In an interview with Nikkei Asia, new Japanese prime minister Yoshihide Suga says his authorities will think about decreasing tax charges to attract overseas expertise as Tokyo seeks to reinvent itself as a worldwide monetary hub.
    Read more

  • Indian tea costs are hovering, with Darjeeling and Assam buying and selling 70 per cent greater than final 12 months due to decrease crop yields and auctions suspended by coronavirus.
    Read more


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here