The impolite individuals who touch upon Derek Lowe’s weblog – Marginal REVOLUTION


Gotta love the logic of bioethicists…

>> Hey guys, can we possibly run a vaccine problem trial to assist speed up analysis? We’ve received 30k volunteers signed up already

Aw jeez, that will be horrible! People are unable to consent to taking a lethal danger! (although lets ignore docs volunteering to work regardless of PPE shortages or troopers volunteering to struggle in distant international locations) We’d hurt just a few hundred individuals with this problem trial so its greatest if we simply run a Section 3 trial and look ahead to months and months to get the outcomes. Who cares if lives could possibly be saved by accelerating the analysis?

>> Hey guys, we’ve received this vaccine candidate that’s solely efficient on younger individuals. Can we simply launch a Section 3 trial for younger individuals whereas we run a separate Section 1/2 trial for older individuals?

Aw jeez, that will be unhealthy! Outdated individuals are individuals too and we’d damage somebody’s emotions if we declare that there’s a vaccine that’s solely out there for younger people. Lets simply delay it by many months as a substitute to the purpose the place it turns into irrelevant, even when it may’ve saved tens of hundreds of individuals within the meantime.

>> People, I’ve received this Oxford vaccine that’s 62% efficient and has no main unwanted side effects. Can we begin utilizing it?

Aw jeez, completely not! Some individuals may get offended as a result of they may’ve acquired the 90% efficient vaccine as a substitute, even when that 90% vaccine is briefly provide and wouldn’t really be out there to them for a lot of months to come back. Reasonably than offending individuals, we must always simply allow them to die from COVID – that method we’re to not blame for something. So lock that vaccine up till you run many extra trials and ignore the truth that this causes tens of hundreds of additional deaths. Bio ethics above all!

Right here is the post link.  From myst_05.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here